The Minnesota Supreme Court has restored a $21.6 million verdict awarded to the families of four young people killed when their vehicle collided with a train in Anoka nearly nine years ago.

The high court denied the Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railway a new trial.

It reversed the Minnesota Court of Appeals, which had ordered a new trial, saying that an error in jury instructions may have led jurors to base their decision on incorrect negligence standards when they found against BNSF. Federal rather than state standards should have been used, the midlevel appellate ruling stated.

In June 2008, the jury concluded the railroad was 90 percent at fault and the driver of the vehicle, Brian Frazier, was 10 percent responsible for the crash. The families argued that the crossing gates had not been working properly.

Frazier, 20, of Newport, along with three passengers - Harry Rhoades, 19, of Newport; Corey Chase, 20, of Coon Rapids; and Bridgette Shannon, 17, of Ramsey - died in the September 2003 crash. They were traveling on Minnesota 47 in Anoka when they collided with a BNSF train at the Ferry Street crossing.

The Supreme Court found that BNSF isn't entitled to a new trial because any error in the special verdict form and in the instructions to the jury on the railroad's duty of care didn't affect the fairness or integrity of judicial proceedings, according to the decision issued Wednesday, March 28.

The high court also ruled that the trial court didn't

abuse its discretion in denying the railroad's motion for a new trial on grounds of new evidence, improperly admitted evidence or the instruction given to the jury on the adverse inference to be drawn from BNSF's failure to produce certain evidence at trial.

Brady Gervais can be reached at 651-228-5513. Follow her at twitter.com/bgervais.